Re: Responsible leadership

Date: Wed, 10 Jun 2009 05:35:19 -0700 [07:35:19 AM CDT]
From: Douglas Ndenga
Subject: Re: Responsible leadership

hello everyone,
Iam glad with discussion for the youth forum,well we have all the power to form youth struggle and human rights and fighting corruption in our beloved country, and the question is how far can we go with this?remember aleader is born not elected.another challenge is,our aged politicians are scared of youths,in that once we get that power,we can spoil there assorted soups on the table.another thing is we have seen some youth leaders being eliminated (assasinated) for the truth they stand for.upto date no one (GOK)has ever come up with truth on there killings.
It pays alot to have freedom,but what we to know justice comes first then freedom.its like going to heaven without death,death comes first then heaven 2nd,so lets pull our minds and reason togather as youths then we heat the ground with one spirit.thanking you all.

From: Linda Wamalwa
Sent: Wednesday, June 10, 2009 10:11:54 AM
Subject: Re: Responsible leadership

Hi People,
I completely agree with you guys on having a party of our own. In fact in many of the meetings that i have attended in the minor youth groups around, they all echo the same sentiments. from having a party to identifying potential leaders to fill all leadership positions.I am for it 100%, my concern is this, as its said,’The branch doesn’t fall far from the tree’, lets please ensure that the leaders we elect will not follow in their predecessors steps. Their character should be tested first, Abraham Lincon ably stated, ‘Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man’s character, give him power.’ Well let me not get ahead of myself, we’ll cross that bridge when we get there, just food for thought. On the other matter of having TV and Radio shows, that should be taken up, the youth in these media houses should do something about it asap.It will do us a lot of good.

Linda Wamalwa
YAA
On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 10:06 AM, Mwaniki Mageria wrote:

Sasa Watu,

I see what you are saying about a mass movement party. Very good idea! Only worry is who is willing to finance this? From little experience working for parties it costs a lot of money every day. No money no visibility. But since there are many ways to skin a cat, let’s be creative in ways of popularizing a youth party. Maybe use youth in media stations to push the agenda? Would their employers allow that? Maybe have monthly barazas at Uhuru Park or suchlike places. Double up as Lower Chamber and Party matters too. If my memory serves me right there used to be a Peoples Parliament meeting at either Kamkunji or Jeevan Gee Gardens. Do you feel this is possible? All we need is a set of conveners across the country.

Let’s get the ball rolling.

Mwaniki

From: muthuri bundi
Sent: Tuesday, June 09, 2009 6:04 PM
Subject: Re: Responsible leadership

Dear All,

This is getting us somewhere. I am pleased and charged by the ideas and from you all.

On TV/ Radio for the group: This is a very good idea that can easily reach and charge the others who might not be subscribing to this group. The challenge now is to the fellows at the media and particularly the FM stations. While i would appreciate the vigor put in by some like Caroline, most of the others need to up the fight. If we could have people with acquaintances to them (through whom we could reach them), i would suggest we sign a kind of petition to have them included in the group or have a way of raising our plight through the media.

The lower chamber: While we could be waiting for constitution ammendment to include this, i think it makes no harm to have a forum in which we could engage the authorities by inviting them (MPS, PSs, Ministers, etc) on a face to face discussion with the youths. This could be possible by having them scheduled weekly or even twice a month through a committe or even through the conveners of NYC. (e.g. L. Otieno live: a citizen tv prog). Here we only need sponser who could then facilitate have it on air through the major media media.

Party: The main problem with the youth are the financial middle class. These people are mostly not willing to be involved in any agenda and are busy perfecting their own. Particularly because they believe that the political class is controlling and are therefore tired of it. By holding these already condemned parties we will not be making any good with it. The only solution is having a new party that is seen as a fresh mind to the whole idea of politics. It is no problem getting the so called “big” people latter when the youth are convinced that its a new crop. Mageria, while heavy weights make heavy weight parties, in this kind of revolutionary move we are taking, heavy weight parties can make heavy weight people. e.g madagascars heavy weight population made a heavy weight.

I fully support Bonnie in what he did. While i might be a coward he isn’t!

An inspiration for you:

“That’s the question before you tonight. Not, “If I stop to help the sanitation workers, what will happen to my job. Not, “If I stop to help the sanitation workers what will happen to all of the hours that I usually spend in my office every day and every week as a pastor?” The question is not, “If I stop to help this man in need, what will happen to me?” The question is, “If I do not stop to help the sanitation workers, what will happen to them?” That’s the question.” Dr. Martin Luther King Junior in speech “I’ve been to the Mountaintop” 3rd April 1968.

With regards
Muthuri

— On Tue, 6/9/09, Mwaniki Mageria wrote:

From: Mwaniki Mageria
Subject: Re: Responsible leadership
Date: Tuesday, June 9, 2009, 3:56 AM

Hi all,

I like Thomas’ thinking. I have some suggestions.

1 while we await the funds to start our own station how about engaging current national and community stations to carry these topics for youth to participate in. Can we identify our own experts in the fields of concern to lead the discussions on already existing stations. They are always looking for fresh and captivating content and this will be providing it for them. Caroline, Fareed, Marcus, Maina, Munene, Ciku, DNG, etc you are all youth. Kindly make this happen.

2 the idea of a 2nd chamber is great but requires a constitutional amendment I guess (lawyers please shed light). This would bridge the morality gap our leaders openly exhibit. Wish we could do it like yesterday.

3 as for a youth party, I think what we need to do is infiltrate existing parties and take over from within. We should seek to be relevant and influential in the current parties. It’s cheaper and we benefit from the infrastructure. If we are focused and persistent in spreading this word thru NYC it is easier to be at the helm sooner rather than later. A new party will require already established names and their funding in order to have the impact we would require. Look at Tip Tip Party for instance. Heavy weights make a heavy weight parties.

Time for action.

Mwaniki

From: Thomas Musau
Sent: Tuesday, June 09, 2009 11:51 AM
Subject: Responsible leadership

Dear All,

I want to contribute to this debate of responsible leadership and good governance which I find very interesting and empowering as well.

First, What Bonnie did was excellent and shows how our political awareness has advanced in the recent past.

I want to say that there are many ways of killing a cat and what Bonnie did was just one of the many. Kudos to him because from exprerience of myself living in the the western world this is a very powerful tool for the oppressed and the powerless to express their disgust to those leaders who have cut themselves off from the common citizens. More Bonnies in future will definitely make a big difference.

Our cat being as big as it is from years governance without accountability and complete disregard of personal responsibility among our leaders we definitely need many more ways to deal with the democratic etiquette breakdown in our country particularly through a youth-led political revolution.

1) My first suggestion is to increase our recruitment drive through the media -even if starting our own radio/TV station dedicated to discussing promoting youth issues about youth, development and the future of Kenya. This radio station can feature role models from across all the the development sector, the civil society, the youth in the diaspora and world leaders alike giving views about how to develop youth talents in all their spheres of life ie politics,business, music,drama and in their other careers and proffessions.

Important national issues can be scheduled on prime hours of the day like evenings for contributions from youth and general public . Such topics could include the constitution, succession battles, scandals in government and public sector with view to encouraging youth to engage wholly in matters of national importance.

2) My second suggestion relates to the current constitutional review; Since the issue of tribalism is as old as when western democracy was being introduced in our country and probably older than that (I am not an historian!) and also because our MPs can nver be trusted where it comes passing laws regarding their own payment as well as their high rate of absence from parliament proceedings I would like the Youth to press for the second chamber of parliament in Kenya.

The chamber would have regionally nominated personalities representative of local communities.

Such people will be people who have wide experience in particular areas eg- religious leaders, traditional value and history experts, retired senior government officialsreknown businessmen people who have excelled in other fields such as sports or even former Presidents and Prime Ministers. Most importantly the chamber to have representatives from various nterest groups such as the Youth, Workers Unions, the Civil society, the Kenyan Diaspora Community and probably the head of certain missions working in areas that would be affected by the individual policies to be tabled. And of course the relevant Minister /Permanent Secretary can be called to attend particular sittings.

To cut the costs for the taxpayers down we can have such posts voluntary and members can only get travel and sitting allowances if nominated .

This Second Chamber (headed by the head of state ) will not have more powers than 1st chamber but the president will have a duty to decide if to pass a bill into law if the second chamber has reservations. In other words the second chamber will have the responsibility of admistering checks and balances to the activities of the 1st chamber ( elected MPs) headed by the Prime Minsiter to make sure that MPs there are not driven by greed and other influences when passing important policies.

Since I have not gone through the current draft I apologise if this is something that has already been proposed in the draft.

But the key thing is the Youth will do Kenya alot of pride if they can sort the issue of tribalism and press for checks and balances to our greedy MPs once and for all through the creation of the second chamber of parliament.

3) My third suggestion is for the Youth to form and register our own political party.

eg The Youth Party of Kenya or whatever name you want to give it – This party will ensure that come the next general elections we shall have a voice of our own, agenda of our own, candidates of our own and even our own President of choice who the National Youth conferederation will choose to back or field.

From experience it is very hard to make a major difference if you work from the peripheri and to have our representatives in the parliament we shall be assured of our views being driven through to the highest policy making organ in the country.

Please note that my reference to Youth does not mean people who are in experienced untested, and poltically challenged but leaders with youthful ideas and who conform to the current changes in political arena across the globe.

With these few i look forward to your responses and meeting you soon when I visit Kenya in August.

Many thanks,

Thomas Musau, UK

— On Tue, 9/6/09, john cheburet wrote:

From: john cheburet
Subject: Re: Responsible leadership
Date: Tuesday, 9 June, 2009, 6:46 AM

Ndenga,

Thanks will look for it. Good day.

Cheburet

“Sometimes it falls on a generation to be great. You can be that generation” – Nelson Mandela

From: Douglas Ndenga Sent: Monday, June 8, 2009 7:42:00 PM
Subject: Re: Responsible leadership

cheburet weldone man also watch, cry freedom you will learn more.

From: john cheburet
Sent: Monday, June 8, 2009 3:30:29 PM
Subject: Re: Responsible leadership

Hi all,

I agree. I’d like to recommend one movie that gave me an indelible lesson on non-violence: “The Great Debaters”, a movie by Denzel Washington, Nate Parker, Forest Whitaker among others . Look for it, find time and watch it.

John

“Sometimes it falls on a generation to be great. You can be that generation” – Nelson Mandela

From: Emmanuel Dennis
Sent: Monday, June 8, 2009 4:49:30 PM
Subject: Re: Responsible leadership

Isn’t the debate getting better,
I would like to bring in a small reflection here

One great man said
“You cannot carry out fundamental change without a certain amount of
madness. It comes through non conformity, the courage to turn your
back on the old formulas, the courage to invent the future” Thomas
Sankara

On 6/8/09, Ngunjiri wrote:

I agree with Kepta on this.

There is a perception that because one can more easily access press
conferences or say whatever they want, then we have dialogue, and we should
not be out shouting. However, I want to remind us that dialogue is about
communication, it is 2 way, I speak, you hear, you speak, I hear, and the
results is either the mutual decision to agree or disagree on a certain
course of action. Friends, this is not what we have in Kenya today. Citizens
are speaking and not being heard, politicians are speaking, and not being
listened to. There seems to be a complete disconnect between the political
leadership & the citizenry of this country, and that is a dangerous thing
for stability. For those who might have heard President Kagame’s message to
the Kenyan political class during the recent prayer breakfast at Safari
Park, at some point he said:

*“For those societies that exhibit features of real or latent conflict, the
single most decisive & pressing task facing them, & their leaders in
particular, is to confront the root cause of instability before degenerating
into conflict or even wars. It cannot be otherwise because real solutions
cannot come from anywhere but from within. It is only the leaders & citizens
of such nations that can fully grasp the high stakes involved and as such
posses the power & tools to arrest the disintegration of their nations” *

What Bonnie did should really scare the political leadership-a middle class
award-winning guy announced on radio he was going to heckle the president in
a national stadium, left the studio to the stadium, sat with the crowd, knew
he would most probably be alone, but still stood up and shouted ‘Unga’! Did
he know he would get in trouble, be ridiculed, maybe worse? Of course did.
But he wanted to pass a personal message to his leaders, and he did. Did he
do it the ‘right’ way? Who are we to judge-we haven’t done anything
ourselves.

What did Bonnie achieve? The media took up his story and now a lot of people
know another way to be heard, he started a discussion that we are all
engaged in, political cartoonists have featured what happened, the president
actually referred to it, and got himself in trouble with religious leaders
coz of how he did it, the political class are realizing the tide is rising
and they will be even more nervous the next time they are before a crowd,
etc (reminds me of the guy who threw a shoe at Bush)

As we go about talking about how we will do the big things that require
10,000 or 100,000 people, to make change happen, some men and women are
doing small things that are keeping the process of change happening. You do
not have to agree with what they are doing, you do not have to want or be
able to do it, but do not shoot it down unless you have done or are doing,
not saying, something yourself.

On this particular process that Kenya has embarked on, history will judge us
by what we did or didnt do, not by what we said we would do.

Ngunjiri

www.kikuyusforchange.com

2 thoughts on “Re: Responsible leadership

  1. Ochieng kh

    Date: Thu, 11 Jun 2009 07:35:17 -0700 (PDT)
    From: Ochieng kh
    Subject: Re: Fw: NYC Re: Responsible leadership

    Thanks for the excellent initiatives. The idea of a party is long overdue. Please proceed with God’s speed. Once more, I am encouraged by the intellectual tinge and the richness of the dialogue/discourse. Best wishes always,

    Ochieng M.K
    Phone Number (Office) 254-20-3861530/1
    Cell Phone Number: 254-723-745-817
    Email:ochykheyr@yahoo.com

    “Do unto others as you would wish it done unto thyself”

    — On Wed, 6/10/09, philippe sadjah wrote:

    From: philippe sadjah
    Subject: Re: Fw: NYC Re: Responsible leadership
    Date: Wednesday, June 10, 2009, 11:09 PM

    Thank you so much for this initiative. I will support this great vision.
    sadjah o.g. Philippe- Machakos Constituency.

    — On Wed, 6/10/09, nicholas oyoo wrote:

    From: nicholas oyoo
    Subject: Re: Fw: NYC Re: Responsible leadership
    Date: Wednesday, June 10, 2009, 7:03 PM

    I have been keenly following this debate and i want to invite us all to what i beleive is a solution in the making for us. For those of us who are of the same thinking it is time for action and not just talk. I have been acting. Let me let the cat out of the bag…

    Why CHAMA? Cha Cha Haki NA Maendeleo (CHAMA) Justice and Development PArty of Kenya (JDP) is in the process of formation.

    Links
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ProgressiveMinds
    http://www.kejude.org/chama.pdf

    Participatory Process in Formation

    The pangs of formation of CHAMA started in November 2008 via online discussions which led to a well attended meeting at a local restaurant on the 17th January 2009. A committee was appointed to lead the process of bringing together over 10 constituent initiatives to form political parties and progressive minded individuals. The committee ended up issuing 3 drafts (A zero draft, 1st draft, and the current draft, the 2nd draft). These were widely circulated in the networks critiqued and input received and processed. The meeting on 27th is a continuation of the consultative character of formation of the party.

    Leadership Vetting

    Arguably, the most important function political parties worldwide are supposed to play is leadership vetting and processing. Leaders emerge because political parties design the processes of identifying them and vetting them to ensure that they are the genuine article. Unfortunately, hitherto, the so called political parties in Kenya have abrogated this role and with serious repercussions for Kenya . The Post Elections Aftermath is one such outcome undoubtedly. The formation of CHAMA is also an agreement that never again will we allow mediocrity in form of leadership selection to allow below par leadership to preside over the leadership spaces in Kenya . Such an eventuality is too costly to fathom. CHAMA constitution was clearly designed to capture this essence as well as make certain that leadership is tracked to ensure quality remains above bar. The constitution has mechanisms such as the recall clause, wealth declaration and publication, tax compliance, certificate of good conduct and binding pre-nomination agreements as the minimum for consideration to represent the party in elective positions.

    Money Bags

    It is no secret that Kenya political arena is littered with characters that are wealthy and use such wealth to score political goals. Political parties have become tools for trade. While others form them for sell and selling of nomination certificates, others buy them so as to ensure that they will have their names in the ballot box at all costs. Talk about going for an interview after you had designed the questions. The owners of the party rubbish the processes of interrogating leadership by buying their own processes. CHAMA intends to tell money bags thanks but no thanks. We plan to recruit at least 2500 progressive minded Kenyans to pledge Kenya Shillings 5,000 for the next three years to keep the party afloat financially and secure its independence. And why not, Obama campaign was funded by the public.

    Party Leadership versus Elected Leadership

    One of CHAMA main credos is that the elected representatives are workers of the party, Party members and by extension, employees of the public. They must stay out of party leadership if they decide to run for office. In Kenya this is unheard of.

    Ideological Base

    The main ideology of Kenyan ‘Political Parties’ is regional/tribal tagging and political zoning. CHAMA aims to return sense to Kenyan political engagement by stressing the republic as a State founded on respect for rule of law, constitutionalism and effective representation at all times where citizens have a right to recall their representatives mid term. We will practice capitalism with checks and balances that ensure the system works for Kenyans, not a few cronies of the ruling elite.

    The Missing Link for Good Leadership

    CHAMA intends to challenge the notion that politics is a dirty game which is a fallacy by the status quo intended to achieve self perpetuation. We want to convert previous apolitical individuals to become engaged in politics so as to foster the arrival of fresh thinking. We are convinced that there are soft background roles for those who want to remain behind the scenes, as well as overt roles for those who can stand the glare> every body can do something in a political party.

    Radical Revolutionary Progressive Thinking

    We encourage thinking like for instance:

    * Economic growth is but just a function of wealth creation and not an end in itself. It must not just be about figures but real development indices clearly seen as well aspects calculated risks by a nation in a bid to secure sustainable double digit growth.

    * Collective interest is the most sustainable self interest

    * If you neighbour is poor you are also poor. That if you are driving in potholed roads or paying double the fare you believe you should pay is partly because your neighbour cannot afford to pay taxes and help expand the nation cake.

    * That leadership is an opportunity and privilege for service and not an occupation.

    Everybody’s Share

    You join the party not via rallies cum recruitment drives where you can ask questions and seek clarifications but only after you have been informed what the party stands for and what your role should be. This is since we realize that members are the best ambassadors the party can have and should be party agents and should recruit by word of mouth and by actions.

    Political Education

    Unlike other Kenyans parties whose tool of trade has been political ignorance, we prefer an enlightened public that can ask questions and push for accountability and services. We feel that progress is secured not by satisfying the customer but taking the customer through stages of growth where achievement means the beginning of the next quest. There is so much room upwards and there is more sustainability in expanding the cake than guarding the small portions. (Many times satisfaction is perceived and not real).

    Non-Partisan/Sectional

    We abhor compartmentation of the society and we can boldly say without fear of contradiction that we seek not to build a Youth party, a Women party, a Party for the Rich or the Middle Class. Instead we feel there is more need to build a party for all Kenyans. It may appear a youth Party because most members associated with it are youth, but that’s just because there are more youth in the society; it may appear to be a women’s party but that is just because women are a majority. The party being associated with certain sections of the society should be accidental as well as coincidental and not by design.

    We target to build an institution that will outlive its founders and remain a leading light in as far as leadership processing and production is concern. We call for you involvement in pushing the frontier of progress in Kenya , Africa and the world.

    The Difference

    This party is intends to be different from the ones we call parties in Kenya . Please click on the links and it will lead you to the group where you can join for you to get direct emails on your email address, post there as well as keep updated. It is the group we set up for discussions on the party matter. Here below are some collected information posted on the group on the party issue:

    A progressive group of mostly young Kenyan men and women, whose dream is to see proper governance and better politics, decided to do something to ensure this dream is achieved. They made use of their virtual interaction tools to carry out the plotting of the beginnings of a better tomorrow for them, their children and the children of those children.

    This cumulated into the setting up of a physical meeting on 17th January 2007, at a local restaurant. With a set target of 60 participants, even a weather pressured day where heavy unyielding rain with all the complications this causes to Nairobi , could not dampen the urge to do something. A quorum of 45 participants from all corners off the country was resolvedly in attendance. Over 10 initiatives intended to form political parties were unified in the process.

    We love to make reference to the US president Barack Obama. After hundred days of Obama presidency at least we are more sober and can look at it from a more objective standpoint. We only love to look at such references when we feel they favour our argument, usually Young people arguing for youthful leadership. Obama is a system. For me, the person Barack Obama happened because there is a well established and credible system of leadership selection, first in the Democratic Party and finally in the US through campaigns and finally elections. Obama had to be put into a telescope for more than four years, most of them as a potential Democratic party Flag bearer and finally as the potential president. he was subjected to more than 4 years of interrogation, participated in almost 30 debates, answered thousands of questions, responded to hundreds of quarries and faced millions of voters and had to beat a fields of over 100 potential candidates at the very beginning of the race before finally being installed as president.

    We convinced that our answer lies in formation of a political party that is reform minded. A party that will place certain requirements on the way for prospective candidates which will ensure the bar is raised. That is what we have been working on. Please find link the party draft 2 constitution. What a political party will do is to give us the platform, credibility and legitimacy of wrestling leadership from the status quo as well as allow us to start fighting for the hearts and minds of Kenyans, early enough. We want to put in place the systems that will help us find Kenya ’s own Obamas. The ones put forth here are just the beginning. Remember it is only through a party that we can take leadership positions in Kenya . We have always thought the party comes last but this time round we need to form the party as the basis of our engagement and ensure it is fine tuned and ready to challenge the big boys even before the time comes.

    Special Attention

    In The CHAMA proposed Constitution, Pay Special Attention to the following
    Articles, among others, that show the difference with the rest of Political
    Parties

    • Articles 5.12
    • Article 12
    • The whole Article 13
    • Article 16.6 (e and f)
    • Articles 19 and 20
    • Article 22
    • Article 23.3 (deliberate and conscious decision to form the party around
    electoral units as opposed to administrative units such as provinces and
    districts which are tribal patterned in nature.
    • Article 31.3
    • 31.4
    • 32.2

    — On Wed, 6/10/09, Thomas Musau wrote:

    From: Thomas Musau
    Subject: Fw: NYC Re: Responsible leadership
    Date: Wednesday, June 10, 2009, 9:29 AM

    I am following this discussion with a lot of interest and from what I can see, we are about to make History.

    I am seeing a youth -led revolution whereby whoever gets into the next parliament will have to have youth rubber-stamb. As Douglas and others who have rightfully expressed fears of elimination from the old guard, the only thing I can say is that there will definitely be casulties in this major political milestone in Kenya and the question is would you rather die in the fight and become a hero or die in flight and no one remembers you after the final send-off ceremony?

    All I can say is that if you choose to be part of History give yourself wholly and do your part to the best of your ability not expecting any rewards except your own personal fulfilment which you get having saved many lives of fellow kenyans from the current crop of hyenas who call themselves leaders.

    As one of the contributors pointed out, we need money to create what most people have suggested- coordinated youth political activities from the grassroot-. we need also to set up an office to operate from and to recruit people who can runour regional offices..

    This means we will need to elect interim national officials who can lead in the registration of our party and who can then approach different funding agencies for support to set up the party. I propose we don’t call it a party at this stage because funding avenues maybe limited because not many agencies provide funds to political parties.

    We then therefore use the same name we have now or a similar one to approach our current funders (if any) and tell them that we would like to set up regional offices branches which will be used as a call-in centres for youth for services such as training apprenticeships, job search and job application support -which the government should be doing anyway from the youth fund.

    The national Governing Committee can then use part of the funding to work on the governing document for our organisation and also to set up the regional representatives who will ensure there will be a national outlook by the time we go public.

    Bottom line is we don’t talk about the party now but instead we sell ourselves as a Youth employement, skills and training as well as political awareness/ community development initiative which later can then be transformed to a political party when time is right.

    I propose we have the current convenors take the fund-raising initiative as a matter of priority and start with the relevant ministry for funding to set up free employment and training advice services across the country which should be centrally managed through our national steering comittee.

    Other possible funders could be western countries through their foreign missions in Kenya.

    When we are fully registered and with all relevant policy documents in place you can then go to independently run grants agencies for funding .

    Let me end by asking one of the founder members of this organisation to write to me directly to explain to me, how the organisation was founded, what you have done so far and who you ahve worked with previously so that I don’t contribute things based on assumptions also to see if there are ways I can help in selling the organisation ideas within the my UK contacts for possible support or partnership.

    Many thanks

    Thomas Musau-UK.

    I

    This is of course the difference between

  2. kneegrow

    Seems like a nice idea. But politicians will infiltrate the group so honesty is indispensable for us to realise our goal. How i wish we could get a lady to lead this movement, with foot soldiers being guys. i am ready also to serve at any level.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *